DXPR Builder (formerly Glazed Builder)

URL: https://www.drupal.org/project/dxpr_builder

Intended Use Case: DXPR Builder is designed for site builders, marketers, and content creators who want to create visually appealing, responsive designs without writing any code.

  • Drag-and-drop interface
  • Pre-built templates and layouts
  • Customizable design elements
  • Mobile responsiveness
  • Inline editing

Pros:

  • User-friendly and intuitive
  • Rich feature set for designing and customizing
  • Strong integration with Drupal's existing functionality
  • UI can be customized per user role
  • Free for small websites

Cons:

  • Requires a subscription for sites that require more than 10 drag and drop pages
  • Customizing UI for user roles takes some effort

Commercial Support: Available through DXPR (https://www.dxpr.com)

Security: Actively maintained with regular updates, stable releases covered by Drupal.org security advisory policy.

 

Acquia Site Studio (formerly Cohesion)

URL: https://www.drupal.org/acquia-site-studio

Intended Use Case: Acquia Site Studio is aimed at businesses and organizations looking for a comprehensive, enterprise-level site-building solution.

  • Component-based design system
  • Layout and style builder
  • Template and content type management
  • Version control and workflow integration
  • API integration and extensibility

Pros:

  • Highly flexible and customizable
  • Streamlines the design and development process
  • Enterprise-level support

Cons:

  • Higher cost compared to other options
  • Limited to Acquia-hosted sites
  • Not easy-to-use compare to most other visual page builders

Commercial Support: Available through Acquia (https://www.acquia.com)

Security: Actively maintained with regular updates, follows Drupal's security best practices, and includes enterprise-level security features.

 

Gutenberg for Drupal

URL: https://www.drupal.org/project/gutenberg

Intended Use Case: Gutenberg is designed for users who want the familiar WordPress Gutenberg editor experience within their Drupal site.

  • Block-based editor
  • Live preview
  • Extensible block library
  • Compatible with Gutenberg plugins and custom blocks

Pros:

  • Familiar interface for WordPress users
  • Supports collaboration and easy content editing

Cons:

  • Limited native Drupal integration
  • No built-in responsive layouts
  • May require additional modules for full functionality

Commercial Support: Community-driven, with limited commercial support options

Security: Actively maintained, stable releases covered by Drupal.org security advisory policy.

 

Paragraphs

URL: https://www.drupal.org/project/paragraphs

Intended Use Case: Paragraphs is suitable for users who want a structured, field-based approach to content creation and layout design.

  • Field-based content creation
  • Drag-and-drop interface
  • Reusable and nestable components

Pros:

  • Granular control over content structure and layout
  • Integrates well with Drupal's core functionality

Cons:

  • May have a steeper learning curve compared to other builders
  • Less visually-oriented design process

Commercial Support: Community-driven, with limited commercial support options

Security: Actively maintained, stable releases covered by Drupal.org security advisory policy.

 

 

Conclusion

After comparing the top four Drupal page builder modules, it's clear that each module is designed for a specific use case. DXPR Builder is an excellent choice for marketers and content creators looking for a user-friendly and intuitive interface to create visually appealing designs without coding. Acquia Site Studio is an enterprise-level solution that offers extensive flexibility and streamlines the design and development process.

Gutenberg for Drupal is perfect for WordPress users who want a familiar interface, while Paragraphs is suitable for users who want a structured, field-based approach to content creation and layout design, offering granular control over content structure and layout.

Overall, it's essential to consider the specific needs and preferences of content creators, designers, and developers when choosing a Drupal page builder module. However, all four of these modules are actively maintained and adhere to Drupal's security best practices, ensuring a reliable and secure page building experience.